click below
click below
Normal Size Small Size show me how
Equality Before Law
Constitutional Law
Case Name | Description |
---|---|
McMahon v Leahy | Man's part in escape was essentially the same as other four, so the State could not seek extradition since it had failed to challenge four others' right to political exemption |
O'Brien v Keogh | Law allowing minor not in custody of a parent 3 years from age 21 to sue for personal injury was on fact establishing equality between two groups |
Nicolaou | Natural father did not have to be informed of adoption of illegitimate child as he could be a rapist, customer of a prostitute etc. |
Murphy v AG | Greater tax liability of married couples living together was not invidious discrimination as it was justified by the particular social function of married couples living together Was however an inducement not to marry |
Brennan v AG | Equality was not relevant to rates on agricultural land as it applied irrespective of the person occupying it |
DeBurca v AG | Property qualification for jury service had no relation to integrity, intelligence etc. |
Lowth v Minister for Social Welfare | No equivalent for husbands required for deserted wives' benefit as wives have a different social function from husbands |
M v Ireland | Man facing trial for indecent assaults on males committed before punishment had been equalised was subject to the lesser sentence as the law had been prima facie discriminatory on grounds of sex |
D(M) (a minor) v Ireland | No punishment for female child under the age of 17 having sex with an underage boy valid in light of different risks and harms posed |
O'B v S | Unequal inheritance right for illegitimate children valid to protect the family founded on marriage |
Re Employment Equality Bill | Cut-off for age discrimination at 18 and 65 was not an irrational or arbitrary choice |