click below
click below
Normal Size Small Size show me how
Intro Module 5 Test
review for module 5 test (the constitution) intro to law - 11/05/2020
Question | Answer |
---|---|
Canada began not as an independent nation but as a colony of _____? | Great Britain |
Describe the 4 main functions of Canada's Constitution. | -to establish a political and economic union based on federal and democratic principles -to outline a framework for the machinery of government and establish governmental institutions |
Describe the 4 main functions of Canada's Constitution (continued). | -to distribute legislative and executive powers between provincial and national levels of government -to solidify and confirm the desire to remain closely associated with Great Britain and its' system of governance and to reject the influence of the USA |
List 3 conventions and practices that were not included in the BNA Act but that mirror those of Great Britain. | -the selection and role of the Prime Minister -the composition of the executive of the House of Commons or Cabinet -the existence and role of political parties |
Which Act and which Prime Minister brought our Constitution home? | The Canada Act & Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau |
When did the Privy Council in England stop hearing appeals from our Supreme Court of Canada? | December 23, 1949 |
"The Constitution Act 1982 abolished and replaced the Constitution Act 1867" True or false? Discuss. | False, it consolidated and amended the British North America Act, 1867 and renamed it the Constitution Act, 1867. |
"The Canadian Charter of Rights is not an Act unto itself" True or False? Why? | True, it is Part 1 of the Constitution Act, 1982. |
Identify the 2 ways in which the Constitution differs from other statutes. | -the Constitution has supremacy over all other laws in Canada -the Constitution cannot be amended as easily as other laws, it can only be amended in accordance with certain rules and procedures set out in the Constitution itself |
Which level of government has residual power over the Constitution? | Federal |
What does the acronym POGG stand for? | Peace, Order and Good Government |
Describe the 3 areas the federal Government has exceptional power under the POGG clause. | -the gap or residual branch (power to govern matters that are not specifically allocated in the Constitution) -the emergency branch (where laws of temporary nature may be implemented, allows Parliament to intrude in matters of provincial jurisdiction) |
Describe the 3 areas the federal Government has exceptional power under the POGG clause (continued). | -the national concern branch (gives Parliament the power to deal with matters beyond a local or provincial concern that are important to the nation as a whole) |
List the 3 areas of activity that can be governed by both the federal and provincial governments. What is this type of jurisdiction called? | -old age pensions -agriculture -immigration -concurrent jurisdiction |
Describe the general amending formula under the Constitution | The general formula (s. 38) requires that seven provinces that make up at least 50% of Canada's population agree to the constitutional amendment |
In which section do we find those matters that are subject to the general amending formula? | s. 42 |
Provide 2 examples of amendments that have to be agreed upon by Parliament, all provincial legislatures, The House of Commons and the Senate. | -proposed changes to the role of the Governor General or Lieutenant Governor of a province -The composition of the Supreme Court of Canada |
Who has power over criminal matters in Canada? Discuss. | Criminal law is a concurrent power between Parliament and the legislature. Parliament enjoys a broad power to enact criminal law for the public good. Legislatures must ground their criminal law in an existing head of provincial power. |
Who has power over criminal matters in Canada? Discuss. (continued) | Section 91(27) grants Parliament the broad power to enact criminal legislation. Section 92(15) empowers the legislature to pass criminal laws on matters under their jurisdiction. |
How does a court decide difficult cases? (government power) | By using 3 legal doctrines: -pith and substance -interjurisdictional immunity -federal paramountcy |
How does the court determine the pith and substance of the law? What does the court then determine? | By examining the law and ascertaining what is the main thrust of the law. They then determine which head of power covers the main thrust of the law. |
What does incidental effect refer to? | The effect an intra vires law may have on the other level of government. If the effect is only incidental, the law will still be intra vires. |
What does double aspect refer to? | The fact that a law may affect both levels of government and can still be valid. |
What is a law if it is passed by one level of government and has more than just an incidental affect on the authority of the other level of government? | Prima facie (on its face) unconstitutional |
When does the doctrine of pith and substance allow the unconstitutional law to stand? | If it plays an important role in a valid legislative scheme. |
What is an example of interjurisdictional immunity and what does it do? | The Employment Standards Act of Ontario, which provides minimum standards to employees |
Who does the Employment Standards Act not apply to? | Workers in federally regulated businesses, such as airlines or banks |
How does the ESA apply to the federal government? | The federal government is immune from the ESA and does not have to comply with it |
When there is a conflict between a federal law and a provincial law, What will happen? | The federal law will take precedence and the provincial law will be inoperative to the extent of the conflict |
What does conflict refer to, regarding federal paramountcy? | The impossibility of dual compliance. |