click below
click below
Normal Size Small Size show me how
Law Making - DL
Delegated Legislation
Question | Answer |
---|---|
Why do we need Delegated Legislation? | Parliament is busy, slow, centralised and doesn't have expertise or focused consultation |
What are enabling acts? + example | Acts that grant powers e.g., Hunting Act 2004 |
What are the three types of Delegated Legislation? | Statutory Instruments, Bylaws, Orders in Council |
What are statutory instruments? | laws made by ministers/sec of state who have been delegated law making power by parliament under a parent/enabling act |
How are Statutory Instruments made? | Drafts laid before parliament by civil servants throughh resolution procedures |
What is negative resolution procedure? | Becomes law if it hasn't been objected to within 40 days. If objected to - vote |
What is Affirmative resolution procedure? | Becomes law once voted through parliament |
What is Super-Affirmative resolution procedure? | Becomes law once voted through parliament + civil servant listens to feedback |
Give an example of a statutory instrument | Justice Secretary has the right to amend legal aid criteria under LASPO 2012 + Hunting Act 2004 provisions |
What are Orders in Council? | Laws made by the king and privy council, but often drafted by government departments then approved |
Give an example of an enabling act for orders in council | Emergency Powers Act 1920 and Civil Contingencies Act 2004 grant powers to the monarch/privy council |
What are Bylaws? | Laws made by local authorities/public corporations under the Local Government Act 1972 |
What are the limitations of bylaws? | Subject to judicial review (quashed if ultra vires), based of home office guidelines, limited to geographical area |
Give an example of bylaws that have been introduced | Coventry Parking regulations, Westminster Act 1999 * (enabling act?) |
What are the delegated legislation safeguards? | Enabling act (defines powers), Res procedure (serious=super), Scrutiny Committees, Judicial Review |
What are two scrutiny committees? | HL Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee, HL Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee |
What does the House of Lords Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee do? | Report if the provisions of any bill inappropriately delegate legislative power to a government minister |
What does the House of Lords Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee do? | Identifies statutory instruments that may be flawed (badly drafted/ultra vires) - toothless (no power to amend) |
What is a Henry VIII clause? | Provision to a bill enabling the government to repeal/amend it after it has become an act of parliament subject to no scrutiny |
What are scrutiny committees role? | look at evidence in a bill - identify if power given is appropriate, look for HVIII, consider what control (-ve...) |
What is judicial review? | A challenge to the use of the delegated legislation (by someone affected) in the Administrative Court/KBD |
When is the use of delegated legislation unlawful? | When it is ultra vires - unreasonable (wednesbury), allowing sub-delegation, levying taxes... |
what is procedural ultra vires? | When you don't follow the correct procedure (resolution procedure?) |
R v Home Secretary, ex parte Fire Brigades Union | Home Secretary exceeded their powers (ultra vires) |
Strickland v Hayes BC | Ultra Vires for being unreasonable - tried to pass bylaw banning singing obscene songs |
Wednesbury Case | Unreasonable = irrational - no reasonable person would have done it |
R v Secretary of State for Home Dept ex parte Al Fayed | Not giving British Citizenship for not having good character is reasonable |
Shamrock Coaches | Council don't give shamrock coaches the contract even though they had the lowest bid - reasonable |
Aylesbury Mushroom | Procedural Ultra Vires - didn't consult one industry |
Advantages of Delegated Legislation | Laws passed quickly (rectify issues faster), controlled (safeguards) |
Disadvantages of Delgated Legislation | Give away too much power (lack of scrutiny), Not democratic (monarch, privy council, ministers - may be lords?) |