click below
click below
Normal Size Small Size show me how
Informed Consent
Torts II - Intro/Informed Consent
Question | Answer |
---|---|
Tort | A civil wrong or injury, other than breach of contract, for which the law will provide a remedy |
Negligence: Elements | 1. Duty - legally recognized relationship btwn parties, req D to act certain way 2. Breach - failure D, meet req'd Standard of Care 3. Causation - nexus btwn D's conduct & injury to P. Factual (actual) cause, Proximate (legal) 4. Damages - $ award, lo |
Breach - Reasonably Prudent Person Standard of Care | D is held to the standard of care of a reasonably prudent person in the same or similar circumstances |
Role of Custom in Determining Breach | Generally, custom/industry practice may be used as evidence of what RPP would do under same/similar circumstances. NOT conclusive test (custom itself = unreasonable/inapplicable under circumstances) |
Professional Standard of Care | Ordinary member of the profession in good standing, under same/similar circumstances |
Malpractice - Physician Standard of Care & Custom | Custom becomes standard of care. Compliance conclusively demonstrates reasonable conduct, while deviation conclusively, unreasonable. |
To prove medical malpractice - | Offer affirmative evidence of custom using expert testimony, unless conduct so grossly apparent, layperson would be able to recognize |
Adopted Patient Rule | Doctor owes duty to inform the patient of all material risks incident to treatment |
Rejected Ordinary Physician Rule | Doctor owes duty to inform of risks that an ordinary physician would inform |
Informed Consent - Material risks | Any risks that would likely affect patient's decision EXCEPTIONS (where disclosure not required): known risks, patient's best interest, emergencies |
Informed Consent | Doctor must disclose all material information, including physician's personal interests in recommended treatment unrelated to patient's best interests |
Standards of Care for informed consent | Physician Rule (majority rule) - ordinary physician standard, community custom determinative. Patient Rule - disclosure of all material risks & alternatives unless obvious, emergencies, patient's best interest |